Friday, May 28, 2010


Previously ranked and blogged at #30
I must admit - at first glance, being an avid lover of all things J.K. Rowling just like every other human being (albeit mostly pre-teens) - I was disheartened to hear the early buzz about Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban's film adaptation was mostly to do with how much it strayed both artistically and plot-wise from the original novel. I mean, the first two films had come out under the direction of Chris Columbus and had played out essentially like film's answer to the audio book. But what Alfonso Cuaron proved with this, the third Harry Potter flick, was that perhaps being a bit unfaithful can pay off in spades. From its complete makeover of the set, the garb, the stylization, and the happy-kid mood of the first two films to the brilliant additions to the original story (yes, I rather liked Cuaron's vision for the Knight Bus), Prisoner of Azkaban is nothing short of a visual feast. It's no surprise that the director of Children of Men and Y Tu Mama Tambien would indulge in a little bit of dark cloud set design, and it more than revitalized the potentially stale movie series. I know it's a very genre choice for me to place so high on the list, but truly - think of a better example of a director's vision so altering an original work to the point of improving on it. On top of the major changes to the set and costume design (loved that the kids were finally wearing some age- and era-appropriate clothes), the mainstays came along for the ride. The acting within the student body (particularly Emma Watson's Hermione and Rupert Grint's Ron Weasley) was vastly improved, and the replacement of Richard Harris, though deeply lamentable after his passing, was a fantastic choice with Michael Gambon. He brought the earnest that Harris offered and twisted it with a little bit of quirk and hipster vibes that Dumbledore seems to carry around in the novels. And where do I begin with John Williams' utterly unique score? Sequel scores tend to be boring rehashes of what's been done before, but from "Buckbeak's Flight" to the Azkaban theme "A Window to the Past," it's a sumptuous soundtrack.

Standout Performance: Hands down, Cuaron is responsible for almost everything great about this movie. His singular vision altered the franchise for the better, even if it was only available for one entry.


Andrew K. said...

Grint will always be the standout - even with all those great cameos. I hope his career takes off after this. Even though this IS my first or second favourite I always hate that he didn't play a part in the finale (yup, a Ron fanboy).

(I liked the old looking clothes from the first two).

Unknown said...

This is the only movie in the series I'd be willing to call actual cinema.
The rest have been just so awful.

Olive said...

I agree with Jose, this was probably the best of the whole series, it had some bite to it. Not too keen on the whole Potter franchise anyhow...

Luke said...

Andrew: He's a very enjoyable actor to watch. He's got that "aw shucks" looks on his face, and it's perfect for Ron. Glad someone else can stoop to enjoy these movies!

Jose: Oh no! Well, I apologize for mentioning two of the others on my 100 list. :)

Olive: Well at least we can all agree that it's the best choice for "best of the franchise." And it really is, hands down.

Simon said...

Certainly. This has always been my favorite of the series.